Top 10 Most Annoying Misuses of Punctuation

DDD_Top10MostAnnoyingMisusesOfPunctuationOver the years as a writer and college instructor, I’ve come to conclude two very important things about punctuation: 1) it’s absolutely critical to good communication, and 2) many college graduates still struggle with it. Punctuation is a visual cue in our language that tells readers not only what the writer is saying, but how they are saying it. Punctuation affects not only clarity, but tone and personality. Used correctly, punctuation can make writing exciting, dynamic, and more personable. But used incorrectly, punctuation makes communication confusing. Perhaps more than anything else, when punctuation is used poorly, it is annoying and tacky, and it can really damage a writer’s credibility.

There’s more to punctuation, of course, than periods and question marks. Most of us know how to use those marks with our eyes closed. But I’m amazed at how often I see problems with apostrophes and hyphens and how few people actually know what an em dash or an ellipsis is. It’s also somewhat alarming how often commas are used when a semicolon should be used instead. To improve visual literacy (or, perhaps, just to help squelch a pet peeve of mine), I thought I’d list my top 10 most annoying misuses of punctuation. 

For a bit of humor, you might check out a few more funny misuses of punctuation.

#10: Using Quotation Marks Inappropriately
Quotation marks have a cool and unique ability to imply sarcasm or to encourage readers to interpret the information for themselves. When used correctly, they are a valuable asset for humor and reader engagement. When used incorrectly, quotation marks raise suspicion and cause unintended gaffes. If a sign reads, Day Old “Bread”, example, you might wonder if it is actually bread, or some other substitute concoction. Here are a few glimpses into how quotation marks can sure make information seem goofy:
Misuse of quotation marksDDD_Top10MostAnnoyingMisusesOfPunctuation_Quotation2DDD_Top10MostAnnoyingMisusesOfPunctuation_Quotation3DDD_Top10MostAnnoyingMisusesOfPunctuation_Quotation4

#9: Adding Extra Dots to Ellipses (…)
Ellipses are a valuable tool in writing. They allow the writer to omit words from direct quotes (not to change meaning of course, but to clarify and condense). When omitting text, three and only three dots should be used unless the omitted text coincides with the end of your sentence (then, there should be a fourth dot, which is actually a period). Where writers usually go wrong with ellipses is when they want to indicate trailing off in thought (as if going on some rant about misused punctuation…) When using the ellipsis to do that, still only use three dots! Trailing off with more than three is just plain tacky……

#8: Not Using En Dashes or Em Dashes (or using hyphens in their place)
En dashes are longer than hyphens but shorter than em dashes. En dashes are used to indicate a period of time, usually in place of the word “to”. So, if your résumé says you worked 2010 to 2012, it should look like this: 2010 – 2012. It should NOT look like this: 2010-2012. Em dashes—which are a sophisticated and useful form of punctuation to create sentence complexity—are longer than an en dash, usually the width of two hyphens, or the length of a capital “M”. Em dashes are often used like parentheses, but they emphasize information, rather than make it a side note (see previous sentence for its use).

#7: Not Hyphenating Two-Word Adjectives (modifiers)
Consider this sentence: “Please bring me a hot water bottle.” If someone wrote me that as instructions, I’d be confused. Do they need a bottle that holds hot water, or do they need a heated bottle? Technically, the way that sentence is written, the person literally needs a hot bottle. If they need a bottle that is made for holding hot water, however, there should be a hyphen between the two modifying terms, “hot” and “water” (a hot-water bottle). See? Confusion erased. Whenever you use multiple words to modify a noun, hyphens should connect the modifiers.

#6: Putting Apostrophes on Acronyms

DDD_Top10MostAnnoyingMisusesOfPunctuation_ApostropheAcronymAck! This happens all too often and it is a sad (and costly) mistake when it ends up on a major sign or billboard. Remember the rule for apostrophes: they are for contractions (like “don’t” and “wasn’t”) and possession. Unless these DVDs own something, that apostrophe needs to disappear. You’ll run across this problem in some of the most unlikely places. Acronyms like “TV,” “CD,” and “VCR” don’t usually possess anything and will rarely need an apostrophe. Just stick an ‘s’ on the end (DVDs) and call it good.

#5: Overusing Exclamation Marks
DDD_Top10MostAnnoyingMisusesOfPunctuation_ExclamationPointsA general rule of thumb is to only use one exclamation mark per document, if you use one at all. Rarely, if ever, will you want more than one exclamation mark side-by-side. Remember, when you emphasize everything on the same document, nothing becomes emphasized anymore. A bunch of exclamation marks just looks like you’re yelling (or being unknowingly obnoxious, which may be worse).

 

#4: Using Colons to Introduce Items
Colons are tricky but they definitely have a purpose if used well. But there is a misconception that every time you list a few items, a colon should go in front. You can reword the phrase to include a colon, but it changes the way the sentence is read. Here is an example of where most people go wrong and two ways to fix it (and notice my colon usages here as well):

INCORRECT: “I’m going to  buy some: milk, flour, eggs, and soap.”
CORRECT: “I’m going to buy some milk, flour, eggs, and soap.”
CORRECT: “I need to buy a few key things: flour, milk, eggs, and soap.

#3: Putting Apostrophes on Last Names (when there shouldn’t be one)
DDD_Top10MostAnnoyingMisusesOfPunctuation_ApostropheLastNameAh, yes, the old Christmas card apostrophe mistake. Remember (once again): apostrophes are for contractions (like “don’t” and “wasn’t”) and for possession. In a Christmas card, the last name will almost never need an apostrophe. And what if your last name ends in an ‘s’? Then you add an ‘es’ at the end of your name (so a card from a family with the last name “Curtis” should read “Merry Christmas from the Curtises”). If you don’t like how your last name looks with an “es” added to it, then reword the card to say something like “The Curtis Family.”

#2: Putting Apostrophes on Years
DDD_Top10MostAnnoyingMisusesOfPunctuation_ApostropheYears
I’m not really sure how this ever became such a trend, but there is a widely spread (but incorrect) belief that apostrophes should be used when naming years (like “1950’s”). Remember (for the third time): apostrophes are for contractions (like “don’t” and “wasn’t”) and for possession. Unless a year owns something, it should not use an apostrophe. Rather, it should simply have the ‘s’ at the end: 1950s.

#1: Using Commas Instead of Semicolons
The number-one, most problematic punctuation problem I see is when two independent clauses (complete sentences) are connected with a comma. Yuck. Connecting two sentences with a comma is called a comma splice (a form of run-on sentence) and it makes reading clunky and hard to follow. If you have a subject and verb on one side of the sentence and a subject and verb on the other side, there needs to either be a semicolon or a period to separate the two. Example:

INCORRECT: The sun is bright today, we need to put on some sunscreen.
CORRECT: The sun is bright today; we need to put on some sunscreen.

18 thoughts on “Top 10 Most Annoying Misuses of Punctuation

    • April 12, 2016 at 2:40 pm
      Permalink

      You know what annoys me? People love to put an asterisk in front of a sentence that looks like a footnote, but they don’t put an asterisk in the main passage. So it isn’t really a footnote at all, and shouldn’t have an asterisk.

      Reply
  • July 23, 2013 at 7:12 am
    Permalink

    What about using apostrophes to show possession by a family who’s name ends in an s or z? I was taught that my friend’s family’s motor home was the Jacobs’ RV. Now, the English text book says it is the Jacobs’s RV. Which is correct?

    Reply
  • July 23, 2013 at 2:31 pm
    Permalink

    Great question, Gina! In times past, you are right, you could simply put the apostrophe at the end of Jacobs (Jacobs’ RV). This is still considered acceptable, but not preferred. The reason is that there is some ambiguity as to whether or not “Jacobs” is singular or plural. When talking about a family, technically it is ONE family, or singular. So, when the Jacobs family owns the RV, it is more clear to write “It is the Jacobs’s RV.” Without that extra ‘s,’ it could be inferred that there are multiple families who possess the RV. Kind of confusing, I know!

    Reply
  • July 24, 2013 at 1:07 am
    Permalink

    In the article entitled, “Top 10 Most Annoying Misuses of Punctuation”, under the section, ” #1: Using Commas Instead of Semicolons”, the third sentence is written as follows:

    “If you have a subject and verb on side of the sentence and a subject and verb on the other side, there needs to either be a semicolon or a period to separate the two.”

    Wasn’t the word “one” inadvertently omitted from the position shown (in brackets)in the following sentence?

    If you have a subject and verb on [one] side of the sentence and a subject and verb on the other side, there needs to either be a semicolon or a period to separate the two.

    Thanks,

    Ed

    PS I hope I’ve used punctuation correctly. Feel free to correct me.

    Reply
    • July 24, 2013 at 2:28 am
      Permalink

      Indeed, Ed! Thanks for catching the typo. Nothing like making a mistake on an article about punctuation. Thanks for setting me straight!

      Reply
  • August 8, 2013 at 10:13 pm
    Permalink

    Could you clarify the proper use of ellipses vs em dashes and semicolons when indicating a pause in speech? My recollection is the ellipses are used to indicate to the reader that unessential parts of a quote have been left out, or a trailing off of thought; however, I see them used all the time to indicate pauses in speech. That is, as I understand it, one of the things a semicolon does (in addition to connecting two independent clauses)–it indicates a longer, more emphatic pause than a comma. Sometimes I see ellipses used to offset an interjection instead of em dashes, or parentheses. It annoys me, but I am uncertain if that constitutes usage.

    Reply
    • August 14, 2013 at 2:47 pm
      Permalink

      Thanks for the comment, Brenden! You are correct, ellipses should be used, almost exclusively, for removing parts of a quote or for trailing of in speech. Almost any other usage will be incorrect.

      Semicolons should ONLY be used when there is an independent clause on both sides. Yes, they do cause a longer pause than commas; what they really do, though, is connect two related sentences without the hard break that a period causes (see how I used it in this sentence?)

      Parentheses are similar in usage to an em dash, though parentheses are best for including related but unessential information into a sentence. In other words, you could read the sentence and skip over what is in the parentheses and it would still be clear. Em dashes, however, break up a sentence by including information that clarifies a sentence by giving emphasis to a particular piece of information.

      Reply
  • August 9, 2013 at 6:05 am
    Permalink

    Great article! Shouldn’t “grandma” in the meme be capitalized in both instances?

    Reply
    • August 14, 2013 at 2:48 pm
      Permalink

      Dianna, thanks for the question! Yes, “Grandma” should be capitalized in the image at the beginning of the article. “Grandma” in this instance is used as a name, or a proper noun, which always merits capitalization.

      Reply
      • August 8, 2014 at 11:51 pm
        Permalink

        The Seven Deadly Sins Infograph stated that, the use of parentheses to highlight words is incorrect. What is the appropriate way to emphasize words within a body of text? Please correct my punctuation and grammar in this sentence–if needed; I WANT to improve my skills. I welcome any advice and appreciate your dedication, hard work and the useful shared resources.

        Reply
        • August 11, 2014 at 3:11 pm
          Permalink

          Julia,

          Thanks for the question! I believe you meant to say quotation marks, not parentheses, correct? To highlight information in a sentence, you’ll typically use italics. When you use quotation marks, you are communicating irony or sarcasm, which may not be what you want. Another common highlighting technique includes using boldface. If you are using a program (like email or blog comments) that doesn’t offer italics or boldface, you can put an asterisk before and after the word, like this: *emphasis*.

          To punctuation your sentence correctly, do it like this:

          Please correct my punctuation and grammar in this sentence, if needed: I wantto improve me skills.

          I hope that helps!

          Reply
  • September 9, 2013 at 4:15 pm
    Permalink

    In the case of years being given apostrophes, would it be in correct to add the apostrophe showing possession to something like music or style (I love 90’s music)? This is likely where the trend started.

    Reply
    • September 9, 2013 at 4:24 pm
      Permalink

      Great question. Yes, if the year is possessive of something (like its own genre of music), then the apostrophe is certainly appropriate. The problem is when people write, “I love music from the 1990’s” or “I was born in the 1980’s.” There is no possession in either of these sentences, so the apostrophes are out of place.

      Reply
  • December 2, 2013 at 1:33 am
    Permalink

    I’m pretty sure that “90’s” is a botched attempt at “’90s,” which is short for “1990s.” The apostrophe indicates indicates omission.

    Reply
  • February 26, 2015 at 4:03 am
    Permalink

    Great list, but I have to disagree with spaces around an en-dash; all major style guides (Chicago, AP, MLA, APA) reference closed en-dashes—just like their listings for em-dashes (except for AP, which prefers open em-dashes).

    Reply
  • April 2, 2016 at 3:18 pm
    Permalink

    But how do you feel about sentence fragments?

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *